Brokeback Mountain (Widescreen Edition)

This movie is very affecting, and well deserves the numerous favorable reviews here.

Like many, I found the film almost shattering emotionally, with a pervasive gloom and bitterness that it is hard to describe in words. One is left with the feeling of wasted lives in an emotional and cultural desert of utter loneliness. Rural Wyoming and Texas of course were and are stuck in a kind of time warp circa 1900, dominated by the most intense fundamentalism and bigotry imaginable. Gay men in such a climate must be invisible if they wish to survive. Although the movie melodramatises this a bit, it is quite true that gay men are in physical danger in such places even today, and certainly cannot make a secure living there.

It is ironic however that neither of the leads is/was gay, at least not officially, nor the director, nor the producers. Ang Lee praised the `courage' of the two leads in merely kissing each other! Most of the sex scenes are largely irrelevant hetero filler, while the homo sex scenes are sanitized, and at times almost unmeaning.

Still, the movie is visually very arresting. The dialogue is not very good; the actors mumble and one is reminded that there is a reason why actors were traditionally trained to ENUNCIATE so they can be heard from more than a few feet away. Even the French dubbing is much easier to understand than the original soundtrack.

The final scene is very moving, or would be if the lighting were better and the dialogue were fully audible.

On balance then, this is a fine movie, and well worth watching several times, but not exactly a masterpiece. For that, the two leads would have to be given better dialogue, and have a lot more convincing sexual relationship. It is somewhat unbelievable that two people would really be in love and not find a way to be with one another more often than twice a year or so over a twenty year period. But the Ennis character is obviously deeply repressed and disturbed emotionally, so perhaps it is not so unbelievable after all that they didn't decamp to California together.

The intense bitterness and hatred that straight men in rural America feel toward gay men is well captured in this movie, and adds a grimness and ugliness to the film that is very unpleasant, but no doubt long overdue - perhaps it will persuade homophobes to relent at least a little, and not automatically identify gay men with Satan in person.

Heath Ledger is generally considered to have been hetero, but there is the ticklish matter of just why he died accidentally/committed suicide. Perhaps his attraction to gay roles was not entirely just a career choice, despite his marriage. Perhaps he was able to play the Ennis character so convincingly because he could somewhat identify with Ennis' situation.

I like many others here would be interested to see the 40 minutes of deleted scenes, especially if they were deleted for sexual reasons.

Brokeback Mountain is one of the best bitter sweet love stories I've seen in a long time! Jake and Heath performances are superb!! The cinematography is excellent, beautiful! You will not be disappointed with this movie!

To call this a "gay cowboy" movie is to sell it short. The heart of this film is "the path not taken".

It is compelling to watch someone look happiness in the eye and walk away from it. This can happen in heterosexual relationships as well. Sometimes people feel that they cannot be together. Perhaps families do not approve, cultural boundaries make it difficult, religious obstacles are too much to overcome, etc. It could happen to anyone, gay or not.

If this type of story grabs you, you should also watch The Lover with Tony Leung and Jane March. As the wealthy Chinaman wrote to his one-time school-girl, he "would love her until death".

How ironic that this alleged "gay cowboy movie" resulted in the real life love story between Heath Ledger and Michelle Williams. Jake Gyllenhall became the godfather to their daughter. We will see Heath's face in Matilda for the duration.

Among other things, I will remember Ledger for his response to all those that called him "brave" for taking on this role. He answered something along the lines of "no, it's people such as firefighters that are brave". What a humble reply from a remarkably gifted actor. We miss you, Heath.

I believe the Actor's Academy fell short this time around. It seemed that Brokeback deserved the Oscar for Best Movie, as Ledger probably merited the Best Actor award. When the chips were down it appeared that this subject matter was just too much for Hollywood to embrace, at least for the time being.

Ok, gay cowboys. I'd heard all the jokes. Still, this one is as good as you've heard. Sure, it gets a little icky here and there. And Jake really does look a little gay. I could barely understand Heath Ledger's cowboy accent, filtered through Aussie. Yet, the story is compelling, and the female stars as the wives are very good, indeed. Watch it. You won't be sorry.

I WONDER IF ENNIS & JACK WERE PLAYED BY GENE WILDER & WOODY ALLEN WOULD THESE REVIEWERS OPINIONS ABOUT HOW HISTORICALLY RELEVENT BROKEBACK MOUNTIAN REALLY IS STILL BE IMPORTANT TO THEM?

ARE THEY DEFENDING BBM SO WE CAN GET SOME MORE HANDSOME CRUMBS FROM THE HOLLYWOOD TABLE?

SICK AS THAT MAY SOUND, ISN'T THAT WHAT HOLLYWOOD HAS ALWAYS DONE?

LET'S FACE IT, DEATH SELLS, AND GAY DEATH SELLS EVEN MORE.

BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN IS A FORMULA FILM. TAKE 2 GORGEOUS ACTORS, PUT THEM BACK IN TIME FOR JUSTIFICATION, ADD TERRIFIC SCENERY, STIR IN SOME WILD GAY LOVEMAKING, KILL ONE OFF FOR THE GAY GUILT SYNDROME AND WHAT DO YOU HAVE? ANOTHER DESCRIPTIVE HORRIFIC MOVIE OF THE MURDER OF A GAY MAN.

SALES WERE GREAT!

THOSE OF US WHO SAW THROUGH THE CELULOID PACKAGING OF BBM WERE JUST CRUSHED TO SEE ANOTHER GENERATION FALLING FOR THE SAME OLD GUILT GAME.